Should You Rent Your Home?

The Pros and Cons of Renting Your Home


January 10, 2024 | M. Cave 


Many people who purchase a new home have the option of keeping their existing home as a rental property. While this can be a great option for many, it's important to be familiar all of the advantages and disadvantages or renting vs selling your home.

Here are some important pros and cons to consider before renting out your home:

The Pros:

  • Potential Rental Income
  • Paying Down The Mortgage
  • Building Equity in the Home
  • Tax Advantages of Real Estate Investments
  • Future Rental for Family or Friends
  • Potential to Sell for a Higher Price Later


The Cons:

  • Potential Wear and Tear on the Home
  • Risk of Non-Performing Tenants
  • Increased Costs of Insurance
  • Tightening Rental Regulations
  • Vacancy and Turnover Expenses
  • Property Management Expenses



Our broker Matthew Cave, was recently quoted in an article on, that broke down many of the advantages of renting vs. selling your current home. Follow the link below to read this in-depth assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of renting your home.

Other Resources

Please be sure to check out our previous post Is My Home a Good Rental? Here we'll discuss what type of home makes a good candidate for a rental property, and steps you can take to assess your home as a rental.

Other Recent Posts

Rental Key Management

By M. Cave | February 3, 2024

February 3, 2023 | M. Cave  A Simple Way to Keep Your Keys Organized In this video we’ll share tips for keeping your keys organized. Here’s what we’ll cover: • The 3 simple supplies we use • How to label keys without tags • Our super simple tracking system Click the link below to watch now! Watch Now! Overview If you’re having trouble keeping your rental keys organized, then this post is for you! I can’t tell you how many times we’ve brought on a …

Read More

Property Management Costs

By M. Cave | December 19, 2023

December 19, 2023 | M. Cave  How Much Does Property Management Cost? In this video we’re going to cover property management pricing! Here are the topics we’ll cover: • The most common fee structures • Ancillary costs to consider • Savings you may see We’ll cover all this and more! Watch Now! Property Management Costs Today we’re going to talk about how much a property manager costs. You may be looking into property management and wondering what sort of fees are involved. Today, we’re here …

Read More

Is My Home a Good Rental?

By M. Cave | December 12, 2023

This is a very common question! If you’re like most people, you have a lot of questions about renting your home, and whether it’s a good option for you. How is the market? How much can I rent my home for? What do I need to do to prepare my home for renting? We’ll tackle these questions and more, so sign up below to get access to this video now!

Read More

M. Cave

Matthew Cave is a Licensed Real Estate Broker with Hudson Property Services, LLC in Poughkeepsie, NY. Matthew has over 20 years of experience managing rental properties and selling homes. He's experienced in a wide variety of property types, but now specializes in single-family homes, condos and townhomes. Matthew enjoys helping Hudson Valley property owners get their rentals running more smoothly and efficiently.